Hello dear
Welcome To East of Chicago Warren
East of Chicago Warren, located at 111 E 1st St, Warren, IN, is a beloved pizza destination known for its inviting atmosphere and exceptional service. Patrons rave about the delightful pizza buffet, which features a variety of delicious options, including unique flavors like Buffalo chicken and dessert pizzas. The staff is consistently praised for their friendliness and attentiveness, creating a welcoming environment for everyone. Signature dishes like the innovative taco pizza and the unforgettable parmPops have garnered enthusiastic reviews, making it a must-visit for both locals and travelers. Whether for carryout or a relaxed dining experience, East of Chicago Warren promises satisfying meals and a cozy charm that leaves a lasting impression.
About
East of Chicago Warren
Welcome to East of Chicago Warren, a charming culinary gem nestled in the heart of Warren, Indiana. Located at 111 E 1st St, this restaurant has become a beloved spot for locals and travelers alike, offering a delightful array of pizzas, wings, and subs that cater to various tastes. With a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, East of Chicago feels like home right when you step inside.
Customers rave about the pizza buffet—a feast for the senses. Imagine indulging in fresh, hot pizza straight from the oven, where aromas tantalize your taste buds even before the first bite. One enthusiastic patron, Mary R, mentioned the carryout experience, noting the "wish you could have smelled that pizza" moments that made their order feel even more special. It's clear that East of Chicago takes pride in timely service and reasonable pricing, ensuring repeat visits from satisfied customers.
As you explore the buffet, be prepared for a variety of choices that go beyond traditional options. Melissa Brinduse highlights the crisp and refreshing salad, alongside unique pizzas such as Buffalo chicken and even dessert pizza! The addition of cinnamon bites with icing captures the sweet side of dining, perfect for those looking to satisfy their cravings.
For those passing through, a stop at East of Chicago offers more than just a meal; it presents an experience. Jaime Fleming described their journey to this little town with its picturesque murals and cozy vibe, where the immaculate surroundings and friendly service made their visit stand out. The attentiveness of the staff—like that of their delightful server—ensures a smooth dining experience. From helpful recommendations to genuine conversations, the personnel at East of Chicago contribute to a warm, inviting environment.
And let’s talk about the food! Customers have gone wild for standout dishes like the parmPops, which Jaime hailed as possibly the best appetizer they've ever tasted. These little bites of parmesan-crusted bliss pair wonderfully with marinara sauce. Meanwhile, the pizza—the star of the show—offers options that innovate and excite. Whether you opt for a classic pepperoni or a creative taco pizza with fresh toppings like salsa, lettuce, and sour cream, you'll likely find it hard to leave any leftovers behind.
In a world where fast food often takes precedence, East of Chicago Warren remains a beacon of quality dining with character and community spirit. As customers like Scott Mattraw have experienced, the team goes above and beyond, even lending a hand with unforeseen troubles—like assisting with a flat tire. This exemplifies the friendly heart of Warren, where the bonds created over delicious meals linger long after the last slice is savored.
In summary, whether you're a local or just passing through, East of Chicago Warren promises a delicious journey filled with mouthwatering dishes, a clean and cozy setting, and a team dedicated to making your visit unforgettable. Don’t just take my word for it; come and experience it for yourself!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ If you like good pizza this is a place to go! They also have a pizza buffet. I ordered carryout, and I wish you could have smelled that pizza on the way like I did LOL! They were timely, friendly, and appropriately priced. We would definitely go back there. ”
“ We were just passing through and happened upon the buffet. The salad was delicious! So crisp and cold. The pizzas were great. Lots of different kinds including dessert pizza and Buffalo chicken. They even had little cinnamon bites with icing! ”
“ Great pizza in downtown Warren! They have great pizza, wings, and subs as well! Staff is always friendly. The buffet has changed in response to the Covid pandemic. They catered a sub employee lunch for my workplace, and everyone loved it! ”
“ After a long day of traveling, we found ourselves on a stretch of interstate with few options. Scanning Google maps for any upcoming options, my son find East of Chicago 17 miles away. Reviews looked promising, but ya never know what you're gonna get in random small towns. Upon turning off the interstate, we were initially worried. We didn't see much of anything. A few miles down a lonely stretch, a darling little town suddenly came into view. As we pulled into the lot for East of Chicago, we admired the quaintness of a cozy small town, complete with beautiful murals on the sides of really old buildings. We hit at an off time... no longer lunch, but not quite dinner either. So there was no buffet but we were ok with that. They were changing out server shifts, so we had to wait just a few minutes, but didn't mind since we showed up at 3 in the afternoon. We were the only ones in the place. It had nice atmosphere. Lots of local photos from over the years. This place was so clean. Including the restrooms which were cutely decorated and had updated working soap and paper towel dispensers. Absolutely Immaculate. Our server was an absolute gem. I wish I had gotten her name. The ticket says Tia, but they didn't wear nametags so I'm not sure if that was her or not. She was very helpful with our decision on what to order. She knew the product well. She had a very upbeat personality and was very outgoing. She gave a perfect balance of conversation, checking on us, and leaving us alone for appropriate lengths of time to enjoy our food and have our own conversations. I could tell she was proud of the work she did and often connects with her customers. She even helped direct us to the local dollar store to buy a phone charger and wished us well in our travels. Such a friendly lady. The food was beyond delicious! We started with the parmPops.... omg, easily the best "appetizer/side from a pizza place" we have ever had. Maybe even ANY type of restaurant! These little parm encrusted bowtie shaped bites of heaven were better than any other breadstick, cheese stick, etc we have ever had. Light and fluffy on the inside, with a delicate crispness to the outside. Excellent flavor. Paired perfectly with the marinara. The pizzas were incredible. Same light/fluffy/crisp as the parm bites. Beautifully topped. Excellent flavor on the cheese. Several innovative options on the menu. My kids opted for classic pepperoni on pan crust. I went with the taco pizza on pan, which far exceeded my expectations. Instead of pizza sauce, they used salsa, then added taco meat, then topped with cheese and baked. When baked, they added fresh lettuce, tomato, olives, shredded cheese, and sour cream. It was like a taco salad on top of a pizza! It was incredible! Our only regret was that we live 4 hours away and won't be able to visit often. 10/10, would visit again! ”
“ I had a flat tire and the staff assisted me getting it fixed. Food was good, and the service was excellent. Great people work at this location! ”
“ Ordered small tower on line 3-4-25, had difficulty with the site, called Warren store to make certain order came through. Order went through, employee super nice, checked our order for correctness, allowed us to change pickup time which online would not let us. EXCELLENT customer service and the pizza was delicious. Worth the 30 minute drive each way. ”
“ This place is SO good! We stopped at the Comfort Inn off of I-69. We were happy to find that they delivered! The entire experience was great, very friendly staff that took the order and the delivery guy was great as well with a quick delivery and friendly manner. The pizza was the BEST!! I’ve never tried the Chicago style, so we went with the Hawaiian and a Chicago melt on the Chicago style crust, it was so delicious! Our favorite was the Hawaiian. Lots of toppings piled up on those medium pizzas, thanks for a great pizza! ”
“ Love this little restaurant! While in Hartford City visiting we always try and make it to Warren for the pizza ! We absolutely love the taco pizza! ”